Allegheny River Fishing Guide: From Pennsylvania to New York

Embark on a fishing journey along the Allegheny River, a scenic 325-mile stretch in Pennsylvania and New York. Renowned by anglers, this river promises varied fishing experiences, perfect for both expert and recreational fishermen. Here’s your guide to making the most of fishing on this waterway.

The Allegheny River in New York is a tributary of the Ohio River. It is approximately 104 miles long and runs through Cattaraugus, Chautauqua, Allegany and Steuben counties in western New York State.

The river’s headwaters begin at the confluence of its east and west branches in Port Allegany, Pennsylvania. The Allegheny River flows north through the Allegheny Plateau region of New York State before flowing into the Chautauqua-Allegheny reservoirs near Jamestown. It then continues northwest through Salamanca and crosses into western New York where it joins the Genesee River and flows through the Allegheny valley before emptying out in Pennsylvania.

The Allegheny River is known for its excellent canoeing and kayaking opportunities, with many class I-III rapids along its length that are suitable for beginners to advanced paddlers. The Allegheny River is home to a variety of fish species, such as common carp, channel catfish, walleye, northern pike, smallmouth bass, largemouth bass and muskellunge. It is a popular spot for recreational fishing, as well as boating and canoeing.

Find other places to fish in NY.

Exploring the Allegheny River

Smallmouth Bass Adventure: In Pennsylvania’s Warren County’s Clarion River and New York’s Salamanca area, you’ll encounter the spirited smallmouth bass or “smallies”. These bass respond well to a variety of lures like soft plastics, crankbaits, and spinnerbaits. Techniques such as drop shotting and jigging around structures are highly effective. Equip yourself with a medium-action rod for the best experience in these rocky streams.

Thrilling Walleye Fishing: The Allegheny River is a hotspot for walleye, especially around the Olean area and Kinzua Dam. These fish are a delight for their fighting spirit and taste. Spring is ideal for observing their spawning. Use live baits like minnows or nightcrawlers, or deep-diving crankbaits and jigs for a successful catch.

Muskie Challenges: These river giants provide an exhilarating challenge for anglers. Prime locations for muskie fishing are near Kinzua Dam in Pennsylvania and Cuba Reservoir in New York. Go for large, eye-catching lures like bucktails, jerkbaits, and oversized soft plastics. Remember, muskie fishing requires robust gear and patience.

Steelhead Trout Excursions: In fall, Quaker Run Creek in New York is a paradise for fly-fishing enthusiasts targeting steelhead trout. These fishes are known for their vigorous runs and are best caught using various fly patterns, including nymphs, streamers, and egg imitations.

Crappie, Perch, & Catfish: Enjoy casual shore fishing for these species, especially during the winter ice fishing season near Olean and Warren in New York. Use small jigs with live bait for crappie and perch, and heavier tackle for catfishing.

Seasonal Fishing Strategies in the Allegheny River

Spring Fishing Tips: Utilize topwater poppers for bass and troll near dams for walleye.
Summer Techniques: Target deeper waters for bass and weedy areas for muskie.
Fall Fishing Tactics: Use downriggers for walleye and fly-fish in Quaker Run Creek for steelhead trout.
Winter Ice Fishing: Enjoy ice fishing with tip-ups near Olean and Warren for walleye, crappie, and perch.

Discover the Best Fishing Spots Along the Allegheny River in NY and PA

Hotspots in Pennsylvania: Visit Kinzua Dam, Allegheny Islands, and Clarion County for walleye, muskie, and bass. Hickory Creek State Park in Forest County offers native Brook Trout.

Prime Locations in New York: Check out Olean for walleye, Salamanca for bass, and Quaker Run Creek for steelhead trout. Chautauqua Lake and Cuba Lake are must-visits for walleye, crappie, perch, and muskie.

Articles Related To Fishing The Allegheny River

4 Great Places to Go Fishing For Smallmouth Bass in Rivers

Drift Fishing for Smallmouth Bass in Rivers Drift fishing for smallmouth bass in rivers offers one of the most thrilling and dynamic fishing experiences. There is a certain excitement in drifting down

FAQs About Fishing Allegheny River

Is the Allegheny River good for fishing?

Absolutely! The Allegheny River is a fantastic spot for fishing. Spanning 325 miles through Pennsylvania and New York, it offers a wide variety of fishing experiences for anglers of all levels. Whether you’re a seasoned pro or just looking for a relaxing day by the water, the Allegheny River has something for everyone.

What kind of fish is in the Allegheny River?

The Allegheny River is home to a diverse range of fish species. You’ll find smallmouth bass, known for their spirited fight, especially in rocky areas. Walleye, famous for their delicious taste and challenging catch, are also plentiful. Additionally, the river hosts muskie, known as the river’s giants, and steelhead trout, especially popular among fly-fishing enthusiasts. Crappie, perch, and catfish are other common catches, offering a fun fishing experience for everyone.

How deep is the Allegheny River?

The depth of the Allegheny River varies along its course. In some sections, it can be relatively shallow, while in others, especially near dams and deeper pools, it can reach depths of 40 feet or more. This variation in depth creates diverse habitats for different fish species, making it an interesting and dynamic place to fish.

Are there walleye in the Allegheny River?

Yes, there are walleye in the Allegheny River! They are particularly famous in this river for their fighting spirit and tasty flesh. You can find them throughout the river, with prime spots near structures like the Kinzua Dam and in deeper pools. They are especially active near dawn and dusk and are a favorite target for many anglers on the river.

Where is the best fishing on the Allegheny River?

Some of the best fishing spots on the Allegheny River include areas around the Kinzua Dam and the Allegheny Reservoir for walleye and muskie. The Clarion River, a tributary, is great for smallmouth bass. For fly-fishing enthusiasts, Quaker Run Creek in New York is a must-visit for steelhead trout. However, local knowledge is always a bonus, so don’t hesitate to ask fellow anglers or local bait shops for their favorite spots.

What can you catch in the Allegheny River?

You can catch a variety of fish in the Allegheny River. The river is home to smallmouth bass, walleye, muskie, steelhead trout, crappie, perch, and catfish. Depending on the season and location, yoAllegheny River Fishing: This is a broad keyword that covers general fishing in the river.

Learn more about the Allegany RIver:

Your NY Fishing Newsletter

FishNY is recognized as New York’s best fishing website. Once dubbed as “the clearing house for fishing content throughout the state” by the Times Union in Albany…