Chain Pickerel Fishing in NY: Tips, Spots & Techniques

Chain Pickerel In NY – Identification, Habitat, Tips, Techniques

Embarking on a fishing trip to catch chain pickerel in New York’s waterways promises an exciting adventure. Known for their sleek bodies and voracious appetite, chain pickerel (Esox niger) are top predators in the state’s freshwater ecosystems, providing both a challenge and a reward for anglers.

A chain pickerel lying on a snow-covered lake beside a float fishing setup.

This comprehensive guide explores chain pickerel fishing, providing insights into their identification, preferred habitats, seasonal behaviors, and effective angling techniques. From the serene lakes of Region 1 to the winding rivers of Region 8, New York State offers diverse landscapes for anglers to pursue this elusive predator.

Join us as we navigate the waters and hidden coves, uncovering the secrets of chain pickerel fishing and creating unforgettable memories in the natural beauty of the Empire State.

Read on – more fish species of NY

How To Identify Chain Pickerel

Identifying chain pickerel, also known as Esox niger, can be an exciting challenge for anglers exploring the waters of New York. Chain pickerel, a predatory species found in various freshwater habitats, possess several distinctive characteristics that aid in their identification. On average, chain pickerel measure between 15 to 20 inches in length, although some specimens can grow up to 3 feet long. 

A happy angler holds out a massive chain pickerel.

The average weight of chain pickerel ranges from 2 to 4 pounds, although the New York State record stands at an impressive 8 pounds 1 ounce. Chain pickerel have a long and slender body, resembling a torpedo, with an elongated duck-billed snout. Their bodies are streamlined for swift movement through the water, allowing them to ambush prey effectively. 

One of the most distinctive features of chain pickerel is their protruding lower jaw, adorned with sharp teeth, aiding in capturing and holding onto their prey. Chain pickerel exhibit a unique coloration, ranging from light-greenish yellow to a dark green on their sides. It’s important to note that northern pike, a related species, are distinctively darker-green in color, helping anglers differentiate between the two species. 

The most prominent identifying feature of chain pickerel is the dark chain-like pattern that runs along their bodies, giving them their common name and serving as a key characteristic for identification. Chain pickerel possess a dark bar or line underneath each eye, and their eyes are typically yellow, providing a striking contrast against their dark markings. Unlike some other species of fish, chain pickerel have fully scaled gill covers and cheeks, further aiding in their identification.

Habitat

Chain pickerel, characterized by their unique features and predatory nature, exhibit specific habitat preferences conducive to their survival and hunting strategies. Unlike many other freshwater species, chain pickerel prefer warmer waters, with the optimal temperature range typically in the upper 70s Fahrenheit.

A fisherman stands at the side of the lake fishing for chain pickerel.

Their habitat is commonly found in weedy lakes, ponds, and reservoirs, where they can utilize the cover provided by aquatic vegetation to ambush prey effectively. Additionally, chain pickerel thrive in the slow-moving reaches of warm-water streams, where they can navigate through vegetation and surprise their prey.

Interestingly, chain pickerel can also adapt to brackish water environments, such as estuaries and tidal creeks, showcasing their versatility in different aquatic ecosystems.

During hot weather, chain pickerel seek out shady spots away from direct sunlight to escape the heat. They predominantly inhabit shallow waters, typically less than 10 feet deep, where they can easily navigate and hunt.

As the fall season approaches and water temperatures begin to drop, chain pickerel exhibit migratory behavior, often moving to the outside edges of weed beds for protection from the cold. Clear waters with submerged aquatic vegetation provide the ideal conditions for chain pickerel to thrive, as they utilize this cover to camouflage themselves while patiently waiting to ambush their prey.

Natural Food Source

Chain pickerel are skilled at hiding in vegetation and ambushing prey. They rely on their keen vision and sharp teeth to catch unsuspecting prey, often targeting wounded or injured baitfish. Unlike some predators that hunt at night, chain pickerel usually feed during the day and are less active at night.

Their diet includes small fish like yellow perch, white suckers, and minnows, as well as amphibians such as frogs and tadpoles. They also eat insects like moths, dragonflies, and beetles, along with crustaceans like crayfish and shrimp. Worms, grubs, and leeches are also part of their diet.

For anglers targeting chain pickerel, understanding their preferred prey is crucial. Using bait and lures that mimic these natural food sources can improve the chances of success when fishing for them.

By the season

Fishing for chain pickerel offers year-round opportunities, with peak activity occurring from early May through July. Even during winter, pickerel remain active and can be targeted through the ice, with fishing generally productive from October to March. Pickerel are active throughout the day but tend to be more active during the early and late hours. 

An angler ice jigs for pickerel.

They are most active when water temperatures range from 55°F to 70°F. Effective baits and lures include spinners, spoons, bucktails, jigs, pork rind baits, and various crankbaits. In warmer water, pickerel respond well to straight or fluke-tail baits like weightless-rigged Berkley PowerBait Minnows or Zoom Flukes, fished with an erratic dart and pause retrieve. 

During spring, pickerel tend to hold in relatively shallow water, particularly around emerging vegetation and shallow points near deep water. Baitfish movements also influence pickerel behavior, with pickerel often found near baitfish pods. Effective lure and fly selection includes Texas-rigged pearl flukes, jointed hard swimbaits, in-line spinners, spinnerbaits, streamers, craft fur baitfish, and wooly buggers. 

While some anglers worry about tackle strength when fishing for pickerel, steel leaders are often unnecessary, with 8 to 14-pound test nylon leaders sufficient for most situations. Pickerel fishing is particularly enjoyable during the spring months, offering exciting opportunities in waters with abundant submerged vegetation and schooling baitfish.

Best Chain Pickerel Fishing Spots In NY

Some of the finest chain pickerel fishing spots in New York State span across various regions, offering diverse opportunities for anglers. The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYS DEC) recommends targeting chain pickerel in Regions 1, 3, 5, 6, 7, and 8, each boasting unique waterbodies ripe for pickerel fishing adventures.

In Region 1, which includes areas like the Peconic River, anglers can explore four ponds known for chain pickerel abundance: Deep Pond, Artist Lake, Twin Ponds, and Forge Pond. Region 2 offers enticing locations such as the Swinging Bridge Reservoir, Lake Superior, and the Harriman Park Lakes.

Moving to Region 5, anglers can seek out chain pickerel in renowned waters like Lake George, Brant Lake, Saratoga Lake, and Lake Champlain. In Region 6, the Black River, the eastern basin of Lake Ontario, and the St. Lawrence River beckon anglers in pursuit of these toothy predators.

Region 7 boasts prime pickerel spots at the south end of Skaneateles Lake, the north end of Cayuga Lake, Madison Reservoir, Oneida Lake, Upper Little York Lake, and Tully Lake. Finally, in Region 8, Hemlock Lake and Canadice Lake offer serene settings for pickerel fishing enthusiasts.

With such a diverse selection of waterbodies spanning multiple regions, New York State provides ample opportunities for anglers to hook into exciting chain pickerel throughout the year. Whether casting from the shores of a tranquil lake or navigating the currents of a winding river, the Empire State offers adventures waiting to be explored by fishing enthusiasts.

Best Chain Pickerel Fishing [Bait, Lures, Flies, Other As Appropriate]

When it comes to fishing for chain pickerel, anglers have a variety of options for bait, lures, flies, and rigs to entice these predatory fish. Live bait is often the preferred choice, with chain pickerel showing a strong attraction to live shiners of various sizes, particularly 4- to 5-inch baits, which tend to lure larger specimens. 

Arkansas shiners, pond (golden) shiners, emerald shiners, chubs, and sucker minnows are all enticing options. In terms of artificial bait, spinnerbaits, casting spoons, and shiny lures can be highly effective, creating commotion and shine in the water that triggers strikes from these aggressive fish. 

A pile of metal shiny lures, perfect for pickerel.

While chain pickerel may not be commonly targeted with flies, streamer flies in white, chartreuse, or yellow colors, such as the Bullethead Darter, can mimic the movement of baitfish and attract pickerel, especially in shallow water.

Additionally, rigs like tip-ups baited with minnows positioned 1-3 feet off the bottom or jigging with spoons, swimming lures like the Rapala jigging rap, or jigs tipped with a whole minnow, minnow head, or spikes can yield positive results. 

When targeting chain pickerel, focus on areas with weed beds in shallow water, where these fish prefer to lurk, typically in depths ranging from 5 to 15 feet. Experimentation with different bait, lure, and rig combinations can help determine the most effective approach based on fishing location and conditions.

How To Catch

Casting artificial lures such as spoons, spinnerbaits, and crankbaits mimics the movement of small fish, enticing pickerel to strike aggressively. Topwater fishing with lures like poppers and buzzbaits can create explosive strikes, especially in shallow, weedy areas where pickerel lurk.

Retrieval techniques like erratic movements and sudden pauses simulate the behavior of injured baitfish, triggering a predatory response from the fish. Fishing near weed beds, fallen trees, and submerged structures can yield successful results as pickerel often hide and ambush prey in these areas. Live bait fishing with minnows or shiners rigged on a bobber or fished on the bottom can also attract pickerel looking for an easy meal. 

A tackle box filled with an assortment of lures that could be used for chain pickerel.

Jigging with soft plastic grubs or swimbaits is effective in deeper water or during colder months when pickerel may be holding near the bottom. Using light to medium spinning or baitcasting rods and reels with sturdy fishing line and leaders helps prevent break-offs from pickerel’s sharp teeth. By experimenting with different techniques and gear while practicing catch-and-release fishing, anglers can enjoy the thrill of catching chain pickerel while preserving their populations for future generations.

Spawning Habits of Chain Pickerel

Chain pickerel, heralds of the spring thaw, initiate their spawning rituals promptly after the ice melts, typically between April and May, marking the onset of the early spring season. Unlike many other fish species, chain pickerel exhibit solitary behavior throughout most of the year. However, during the spawning season, one or two male pickerel will accompany a female, forming a brief but essential partnership for reproduction.

Seeking out swampy or marshy backwater areas, adult chain pickerel embark on their migration to find suitable spawning grounds. Once located, the female chain pickerel deposits her eggs onto various surfaces, including vegetation, submerged branches, and other available substrates. Remarkably, a single adult female chain pickerel can release up to 5000 eggs in one spawning event, ensuring the potential for a robust offspring population.

After the eggs are laid, they undergo a developmental journey lasting approximately 6 to 12 days before hatching. During this crucial period, the parent pickerel diligently guard the nest, protecting the precious eggs from potential threats and predators lurking in the aquatic environment.

Once hatched, the young chain pickerel emerge as miniature versions of their adult counterparts, inhabiting the shallow waters near the shorelines of their spawning grounds. This proximity to the shoreline provides ample protection and access to food sources, fostering the growth and development of the young pickerel in their formative stages.

The early spawning behavior of chain pickerel serves a dual purpose: it maximizes the chances of survival for the young offspring by allowing them to grow larger than competing fish species and newly hatched organisms, while also ensuring the perpetuation of the chain pickerel population in the vibrant ecosystems they inhabit.

Regulations

In New York State, Chain Pickerel reigns as a beloved game fish, drawing anglers to the serene waters throughout the region. To ensure the sustainability of Pickerel populations, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) has instituted specific regulations governing their capture.

The fishing season for Chain Pickerel extends from May 1 to March 15th, providing ample opportunity for anglers to pursue this coveted species. However, to safeguard the health and longevity of Pickerel stocks, certain criteria must be met. According to DEC regulations, Chain Pickerel must measure a minimum of 15 inches in length to be legally retained. Furthermore, anglers are restricted to a daily catch limit of 5 Pickerel per person.

It is imperative for anglers to remain vigilant of regional variations in angling periods and size limits, as regulations may differ across different watersheds and bodies of water. Local regulations play a crucial role in maintaining the ecological balance and sustainable harvest of Chain Pickerel populations.

In addition to size and catch limits, the DEC actively discourages the stocking of Chain Pickerel outside of their native range. Introducing Pickerel into non-native ecosystems poses significant risks to local biodiversity and can disrupt delicate aquatic habitats. Therefore, anglers are urged to refrain from the unauthorized relocation of Chain Pickerel to safeguard the integrity of New York’s aquatic ecosystems.

Chain Pickerel and Related Articles

History and Native American Influence Great Sacandaga Lake Fishing The area now covered by Great Sacandaga Lake was once a thriving valley, nurtured by the Sacandaga River and its tributaries. This fertile

Muskellunge fishing in New York State provides anglers with thrilling opportunities. Learn about top spots, seasonal patterns, and strategies to catch this prized predator.
New York State is home to excellent northern pike fishing. Explore the best spots, seasonal patterns, and expert techniques to catch this fierce game fish.

Your NY Fishing Newsletter