Seneca Lake Fishing – Seasonal Tips & Techniques

Anglers are drawn to Seneca Lake for its diverse fish population, which includes sought-after species such as brown trout, lake trout, rainbow trout, largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, northern pike, yellow perch, and Atlantic salmon.

A fly fisherman holds a large rainbow trout proudly for a photo.

Seneca Lake, spanning an impressive 38 miles in length with a maximum width of approximately 3 miles, holds a significant presence in Ontario, Yates, Seneca, and Schuyler Counties in New York State. The lake is surrounded by the towns of Geneva, Lodi, Romulus, Milo, Hector, and Watkins Glen, creating a diverse backdrop for its expansive waters.

What sets Seneca Lake apart from other Finger Lakes in the area is its unique distinction as the deepest of the Finger Lakes, with a maximum depth of 618 feet achieved in the center of the lake, east to west, of the between Camp Seneca and Lodi Point State Marine Park.This remarkable depth contributes to a distinct ecological landscape, offering anglers a one-of-a-kind fishing experience and the opportunity to enjoy the full range of fishing techniques from shallow-water fishing with planner boards, shore fishing with floats, and spin fishing to deep-water fishing or trolling with downriggers.

A graphic of a float sitting ontop of the water's surface.

Seasonal Fishing Techniques by Species

Spring (March-May)

Spring on Seneca Lake marks the awakening of diverse fishing opportunities. Anglers can target landlocked Atlantic salmon, a standout species known for active feeding during this season.

Landlocked salmon are one of the hardest fighting fish (pound for pound) that can be targeted on Seneca Lake and are well sought after by local anglers. Fishing techniques like trolling with spoons or stick baits at various depths can prove effective. 

Additionally, lake trout, although facing challenges, are still catchable using flasher and fly combinations. As the weather warms, smallmouth bass become more active, and casting along rocky shorelines or using soft plastics can yield success.

Spring is also a promising time for northern pike enthusiasts, with techniques like dead baiting or casting large spinners. Smaller northern pike can be found along the edge of the lake amongst the reeds, whereas larger female pike are usually found in the deeper waters towards the bottom of the lake.

Summer (June-August)

Summer invites anglers to explore the diverse fishery of Seneca Lake. Smallmouth bass continues to be a primary target, with topwater lures or soft plastics enticing strikes near structures.

As the waters warm, consider switching techniques. Try trolling for lake trout using downriggers or lead-core lines, focusing on varying depths. Landlocked Atlantic salmon, although smaller in size, remain catchable with trolling methods and smaller-sized spoon lures.

Summer provides an ideal window for targeting the northern pike on Seneca Lake. Employing fishing techniques like casting large spoons or utilizing live bait in weedy areas can entice these formidable predators. However, it’s crucial to strike quickly during the summer months, as pike tend to strike more aggressively at the bait.

A young angler plays a fish on his fly rod while a man approaches him to net it.

Swift reactions help minimize the risk of deep hooking, a common occurrence in the heightened aggression of summer. This precaution ensures a more successful and sustainable pike fishing experience during the warmer season.

Fall (September-November)

Fall signals a shift in target species on Seneca Lake. Anglers can focus on lake trout, taking advantage of their increased activity as temperatures cool. Trolling with spoons or stick baits at varying depths can yield productive results.

Smallmouth bass remain active, with casting or trolling along drop-offs and rocky structures proving effective. Walleyes, often overlooked, become more viable targets in the fall and can provide great sport on lighter tackle.

 An angler showcases his catch, a large walleye.

Consider casting or trolling with crankbaits near deeper structures. As the lake transitions, adapt your strategies to the changing behavior of the fish for a successful fall fishing experience.

Winter (December-February)

Winter opens up unique opportunities for anglers on Seneca Lake. Ice fishing for northern pike becomes a popular pursuit, with dead baiting or using large jigs near weed beds enticing strikes.

Lake trout are still catchable through the ice using techniques like jigging with lures or bait. Landlocked Atlantic salmon may also be targeted with similar ice-fishing methods.

An enthusiastic fisherman holds a lake trout he caught while fishing from a boat.

Adjust your approach based on ice conditions and the movement patterns of the fish. Winter fishing on Seneca Lake offers a distinct and rewarding experience for those willing to brave the cold.

What Seneca Lake is Known For

In May 2004, Justin, also known as Bling Bling from Newfoundland, PA, achieved a remarkable feat by landing a sizable lake trout from Seneca Lake. The catch was made using down riggers and planner boards with a variety of spoons and lures. Trolling in 60 to 100 feet of water, Bling Bling found success running spoons at approximately 55 feet and a speed of between 1.9 and 2.3 MPH.

A selection of spoons used as fishing lures.

This catch not only showcased the abundance of lake trout but also highlighted the success of various fishing techniques employed on Seneca Lake. Seneca Lake boasts a rich history of fishing accomplishments and facts.

Notably, Seneca Lake’s rainbow trout population is sustained through natural reproduction in Catherine Creek (at the lake’s southern end) and its tributaries, emphasizing the importance of catch and release for this species. Fishing derbies, such as the National Lake Trout Derby held every Memorial Day weekend, add excitement to the local fishing scene.

Beyond fishing, Seneca Lake offers a plethora of activities, events, and attractions for both locals and visitors. The Seneca Lake Wine Trail hosts various events throughout the year, allowing wine and food enthusiasts to explore the region’s wineries and indulge in unique pairings.

Notable events include the Chocolate & Wine Festival, Winter Warm Up and Wine, and the Seneca Lake Wine & Experience Auction. The Finger Lakes region, including Seneca Lake, is known for its vibrant festivals, live music, theater performances, and recreational activities. The stunning landscape and cultural events make Seneca Lake a year-round destination for those seeking a perfect blend of outdoor adventure and community festivities.

Boat Ramps, Boat Launches, Marinas, and Public Access Points

Seneca Lake, situated in Seneca, Ontario, Yates, and Schuyler Counties, provides multiple access points for individuals interested in boating and fishing.

In Seneca County, Seneca Lake State Park offers public access with hard surface ramps, pump-out facilities, and parking for 30 cars with trailers. This site is located on Route 5 and 20 and 96A at the City of Geneva.

Additionally, Lodi Point State Marine Park, situated off County Road 136, 5 miles west of the Village of Lodi, provides a hard surface ramp and parking for 68 cars and trailers. Sampson State Park, located on Route 96A, 12 miles south of the City of Geneva, features concrete ramps, pump-out facilities, and parking for 64 cars and trailers.

All three sites are operated by the Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation. For detailed directions, visitors can refer to the Boat Launch Sites for Seneca County page.

In Ontario County, the Geneva Chamber of Commerce provides public access in the city of Geneva on Route 5 and 20. This location offers free launch ramps and temporary dockage, and it is operated by the City of Geneva.

For more information, including Google Maps driving directions, interested individuals can visit the Boat Launch Sites for Ontario County page.

Yates County offers Severne Point as a public access point, located on Severne Point Road, off Route 14, 8 miles south of Dresden. Operated by the DEC, Severne Point features a hard surface ramp and parking for 12 cars and trailers. It is noted as a good winter launch site, and additional information can be found on the Boat Launch Sites for Yates County page.

In Schuyler County, Smith Memorial Park, located at 5303 Park Avenue, Hector, NY, off Route 414 in Hector, offers a dirt and gravel launch with a steep dirt access road. Although launching boats is not recommended, winter launching is possible, and a fee may apply.

Operated by the Town of Hector, this site provides specific details on the Boat Launch Sites for Schuyler County page. Watkins Glen, located off Route 414 on the canal portion of Catherine Creek, features hard surface ramps, parking for approximately 60 cars with trailers, and charges a fee. This site is operated by the Village of Watkins Glen, and additional information can be found on the Boat Launch Sites for Schuyler County page.

See more of our favorite fishing lakes and rivers.

Articles Related to Seneca Lake Fishing

Seneca Lake in NY offers exceptional fishing for lake trout, bass, and perch. Enjoy year-round opportunities, seasonal techniques, and vibrant local fishing culture.
Keuka Lake in NY offers diverse fishing opportunities with seasonal tips, popular fish species, and convenient access points for anglers of all levels.
Cayuga Lake offers exciting fishing opportunities with seasonal techniques, a variety of fish species, and convenient boat ramps and access points for anglers.

Seneca Lake Fishing: The Yellow Gold of the Finger Lakes Seneca Lake, often referred to as the Lake Trout Capital of the World, is also a hotspot for perch anglers, particularly those

Characteristics and Behavior of “Waterwolves” (Northern Pike and Related Species) While fishing the finger lakes you will come across “Waterwolves” this is a term commonly used to describe predatory freshwater fish, particularly

Planning Some Spring Fishing On Seneca Lake Planning a spring fishing trip on Seneca Lake felt like a long time coming. Living on Port Bay in Wayne County, with Lake Ontario practically

Lake trout are among the most sought-after game fish in New York’s Finger Lakes region, thriving in eight of the eleven lakes. Summer is an ideal time for anglers to target these

FAQs About Fishing Seneca Lake

Seneca Lake offers excellent fishing opportunities, thanks to a robust fishery that has benefited from consistent annual stocking of hatchery-reared lake trout, brown trout, and landlocked salmon. One notable aspect of Seneca Lake’s fishery is the sustainability of its rainbow trout population, which is primarily maintained through natural reproduction. The lake’s fishery is particularly attractive to anglers seeking diverse and rewarding experiences, with various species contributing to the appeal of fishing in Seneca Lake.

Seneca Lake is home to monster carp, with some individuals weighing over 40 pounds. Among the Finger Lakes, Seneca Lake stands out for the presence of carp, and the lake has the potential to produce impressive specimens exceeding 30 pounds. The diversity of fish species, including carp, adds an exciting dimension to the angling opportunities in Seneca Lake, appealing to those interested in pursuing a variety of fishing experiences.

For anglers seeking large lake trout or Atlantic salmon, Cayuga and Seneca lakes are identified as top choices. These lakes offer favorable conditions for catching sizable specimens of these sought-after species. Keuka Lake, on the other hand, is highlighted for those interested in sheer numbers of lake trout. Additionally, if rainbow trout are the target, Skaneateles Lake is renowned for their abundance, while Cayuga, Seneca, or Canandaigua lakes are known for producing larger-sized rainbow trout.

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required for individuals aged 16 and older to engage in fishing at all ponds on the Finger Lakes National Forest, including Seneca Lake. Anglers must adhere to the guidelines and regulations set forth by the New York Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC). This ensures responsible and sustainable fishing practices in the Finger Lakes region.

Lake trout in Seneca Lake are typically caught through trolling using spoons or minnow-like plugs attached to wire-line rigs or downriggers. Alternatively, bottom fishing with whole or cut fish can also be effective. Understanding the preferred methods for catching lake trout enhances the angling experience on Seneca Lake. Captain Joe recommends using jigs, especially during peak biting times, providing anglers with valuable insights for a successful fishing outing.

When targeting lake trout, anglers should opt for light lures, such as small spinners and spoons. Live bait options, including nightcrawlers, salmon eggs, or minnows that mimic the native prey of lake trout, can also be effective. This knowledge about bait preferences adds to the angler’s toolkit for successfully catching lake trout in Seneca Lake.

List of online source references

Your NY Fishing Newsletter