Night Fishing in New York: Ultimate Guide & Top Spots

A Comprehensive Guide to Night Fishing In New York

As the sun sets over the iconic skyline of New York, a different kind of adventure awaits anglers who seek to explore night fishing. New York’s waterways, teeming with diverse aquatic life, come alive under the cover of darkness, offering a unique and exhilarating experience for those willing to cast their lines when the city sleeps. 

More about fishing techniques for beginners and pros alike

A fisherman stands on the dock at a lake as the sun sets.

This guide delves into night fishing in New York, offering insights, tips, and strategies for anglers. From the Hudson River to the Finger Lakes, explore the unique opportunities each body of water provides after dark. Discover why night fishing is captivating, including heightened fish activity and the serene ambiance of moonlit landscapes. Uncover how this guide can turn the darkness into an advantage for your fishing adventures.

What is Night Fishing?

Night fishing involves the practice of fishing during the nighttime hours, typically after sunset and before sunrise. In New York State, this is a popular and legal recreational activity governed by specific regulations set by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC). 

Anglers engage in night fishing for various species such as bass, trout, walleye, and catfish. To partake in this activity, individuals need to be aware of fishing seasons, catch limits, and size restrictions outlined by NYSDEC regulations. 

 A large brown trout caught at nighttime.

Proper equipment, including suitable rods, reels, bait, and lighting such as headlamps, is essential for a successful and safe night fishing experience. Anglers often adjust their techniques, using noise-making lures or those with reflective surfaces, as some fish species are more active during the dark hours. Safety considerations, including informing someone of plans, having a charged phone, and being mindful of weather conditions, are crucial aspects of night fishing in New York State.

Why is Night Fishing Popular?

The sun fully sets on a lake.

Night fishing is popular for several reasons: many fish species become more active at night, making it easier to catch them. With fewer anglers out and cooler temperatures, night fishing offers a more peaceful and comfortable experience. The tranquility and reduced competition enhance the fishing ambiance, while overcoming visibility challenges adds to the adventure. Additionally, night fishing is a social activity, providing a chance to bond with friends or family, and it offers a break from daytime routines.

Night Fishing  – Popular Species

New York offers diverse opportunities for night fishing, with several popular species sought after by anglers. Striped bass is a prime target and is often found in the Hudson River, Long Island Sound, and the East River. During the night, these predatory fish move closer to shorelines, bridges, and piers, making them accessible to anglers. Techniques such as live bait, such as eels or herring, and artificial lures like swimbaits and topwater plugs are effective for enticing striped bass in low-light conditions.

A lure fisherman prepares to fish in the dark for striper bass.

Bluefish, commonly found in the waters around Montauk, Fire Island, and the South Shore, are particularly active at night. Casting large plugs or metal jigs can attract their attention. Fishing near inlets, where baitfish concentrate, is a productive strategy. Employing wire leaders is advisable due to the bluefish’s sharp teeth.

The New York Harbor and its surrounding waters harbor a variety of species, including fluke (summer flounder). Night fishing for fluke can be successful around underwater structures and drop-offs. Drifting with live bait like squid or spearing, along with bucktail jigs, can yield positive results. Anglers often target the Staten Island and Coney Island areas for fluke during the night.

Blackfish, or tautog, are prevalent around Long Island’s rocky structures and wrecks. Night fishing for blackfish involves using green crabs or Asian crabs as bait, presented on a bottom rig with a sinker. Patience is key when targeting blackfish, as they can be slow to bite.

The Long Island Sound and its tributaries offer excellent opportunities for night anglers targeting species like weakfish. Commonly found near marshy areas, weakfish respond well to live bait such as shrimp or small baitfish, as well as soft plastic lures. Casting around lighted docks or using submersible fishing lights can increase your chances of success.

For additional excitement, consider targeting walleye during night fishing trips. Walleye are known for their nocturnal feeding habits, making them a popular target after sundown. In New York, bodies of water such as Lake Erie, Lake Ontario, and the Finger Lakes offer opportunities for night walleye fishing. Techniques like trolling with deep-diving crankbaits or using live bait such as minnows can be effective.

Moreover, anglers seeking the thrill of night fishing can explore pike, musky, and brown trout fishing. Brown trout, known to feed three times more at night, make them an enticing target for nocturnal anglers. Focus on areas with submerged structures, deep pools, or tributaries for brown trout during the night. Using live bait such as nightcrawlers or streamer flies can be effective in enticing these elusive fish.

A stunning brown trout displayed by an angler.

Regardless of the targeted species, it is crucial to familiarize yourself with local regulations, obtain the necessary permits, and practice ethical angling to ensure the sustainability of the fisheries. Always consider safety precautions when engaging in night fishing activities, including appropriate lighting and navigation equipment.

New York’s Popular Night Fishing Locations 

 A large northern pike held by an angler.

New York offers diverse night fishing spots: the Hudson River and East/Harlem Rivers are great for striped bass. Shinnecock and Great South Bays are ideal for bluefish. Jamaica Bay excels for fluke, while South Shore wrecks are perfect for blackfish. Lake Champlain is known for pike and musky, and Catskill Creek is a good spot for brown trout. North Shore inlets are excellent for weakfish, Oneida Lake for walleye, Cayuga Lake for lake and rainbow trout, and Sodus Bay for panfish.

Key Equipment

For successful night fishing, use a sensitive rod and reel combo suitable for your target species. Choose high-quality fishing line and brightly colored or luminescent baits and lures. Equip yourself with a reliable headlamp or flashlight, and ensure your boat has proper navigation lights and a green light to attract baitfish. 

Use a fish finder with GPS for navigation and fish location. Organize your tackle box with glow-in-the-dark terminal tackle. Wear comfortable, weather-appropriate clothing, and bring a thermal blanket, insect repellent, and camping gear if needed. A portable fire pit and camp stove or grill are useful for warmth and cooking.

Two fishermen sit beside their fishing rods in the dark dressed in comfortable clothing.

For safety, carry a first aid kit with bandages, antiseptic wipes, pain relievers, tweezers, scissors, and any necessary prescription medications. Include a multipurpose tool for cutting or opening items. Use LED headlamps with adjustable brightness and red light modes for visibility. Invest in bite alarms and rod tip lights to monitor fishing activity and detect bites at night. Proper gear and safety measures will ensure a successful and enjoyable night fishing adventure.

Best Times to Night Fish in New York

Two bait rods setup at night fishing a calm lake.

Night fishing in New York is most effective from 8:00 p.m. to 3:00 a.m., especially on clear, calm nights. Fish are more active in tranquil conditions after sunset, so avoid windy or rough waters.

Summer nights are ideal due to cooler water temperatures, making fish like catfish more accessible. Fish adapt well to low-light conditions and are more active at night. Use black lures to highlight bait silhouettes, but also experiment with neon colors like yellow, pink, or orange.

Advanced Night Fishing Techniques

A fisherman sleeps with one hand still on his rod.

Night fishing requires advanced techniques for success. Key strategies include:

Silence: Use noise-reducing gear like quiet reels and muted footwear. Employ soft casting techniques and quiet trolling motors to minimize disturbances.

Lunar Intelligence: Fish behavior varies with moon phases. Track lunar calendars to optimize fishing times based on moon visibility.

Temperature Dynamics: Fish activity is influenced by water temperature. Use temperature gauges to identify thermoclines and adjust fishing depth and bait accordingly.

Subsurface Tactics: Target deeper waters with glow-in-the-dark lures and soft plastics. Experiment with retrieval speeds and patterns in low light.

Patience: Choose strategic locations and monitor equipment closely. Be patient and wait for subtle bites, as this approach increases the chances of catching nocturnal fish.

Night Fishing Safety 

To ensure safety while night fishing, use high-quality, waterproof navigation lights and bright, non-glaring deck lights to improve visibility and prevent accidents. Equip your vessel with reliable GPS, radar, and sonar, and keep navigation charts up to date. Have emergency communication tools like VHF radios, flares, and EPIRBs ready. 

Monitor weather conditions with real-time tools and ensure crew training in nighttime navigation and emergency procedures. Wear Personal Protective Equipment (PPE), including life jackets with lights, and regularly check all safety gear. 

Always inform someone of your plans, stay connected with communication devices, and avoid fishing in areas with rising water or hazardous conditions like estuaries. Never fish alone—always go with a team for better safety and support.

FAQ's

What are some popular night fishing locations in New York?

Popular night fishing locations in New York include the Hudson River, East River, Harlem River, Shinnecock Bay, Great South Bay, Jamaica Bay, Lake Champlain, Catskill Creek, Huntington and Northport inlets, Oneida Lake, Cayuga Lake, and Sodus Bay.

Night fishing in New York is popular due to altered fish behavior during nighttime hours, reduced recreational pressure, tranquility of the nighttime atmosphere, cooler temperatures, social aspects, regulatory opportunities, and the opportunity to escape daytime obligations.

Popular species for night fishing in New York include striped bass, bluefish, fluke (summer flounder), blackfish (tautog), weakfish, walleye, pike, musky, brown trout and crappie.

Safety measures for night fishing in New York include proper lighting on boats, advanced navigation tools, staying vigilant about weather conditions, personal protective equipment (PPE) such as life jackets and reflective clothing, regular maintenance checks, informing others about plans, staying connected through reliable communication devices, avoiding water that rises overnight, and practicing a team approach by not fishing alone.

Advanced night fishing techniques include noise reduction gear for stealth, tracking lunar phases for strategic planning, understanding temperature dynamics with high-tech gauges, using subsurface tactics with glow-in-the-dark lures, and emphasizing patience by choosing strategic locations and closely monitoring equipment for subtle bites.

Night Fishing Articles

  Best Time To Fish For Muskie – Summer Nights! While fall undoubtedly offers some of the best muskie fishing of the year, particularly during the cooler months when the fish are

Your NY Fishing Newsletter