Keg Creek – An Awesome Angling Alternative

The Keg Creek — *Keg Creek – one of the finest spring rainbow trout streams in New York State.*

Each year, anglers flock to the eighteen-mile stretch of Keg Creek in the town of Burt, New York, seeking the thrill of landing game fish. The creek plays host to a large run of Lake Ontario steelhead, making it a prime fishing destination during both the fall and spring seasons. The fall features a dramatic influx of salmon, wild brown trout, and steelhead, while the spring sees another exciting run of steelhead as the weather warms.

Once the fall salmon make their upstream charge, steelhead and wild brown trout follow closely behind. As the spring rains swell and warm the waters, more wild brown trout make their way up the stream, turning the short but productive section into a hotspot for anglers. During the spring peak, Burt Dam draws crowds from all over New York, but the area can become overcrowded, and water conditions can change unpredictably.

Just a short ten-minute drive from Burt Dam, however, is Keg Creek. This quiet creek drains a large area and is nestled between a peaceful apple orchard and comfortable woodlands, providing anglers a serene setting just a stone’s throw from Lake Ontario. What makes Keg Creek even more appealing is its steelhead run, which mirrors the one at Burt Dam but with far fewer fishermen. The size and consistency of the steelhead run make Keg Creek an ideal alternative to the heavily trafficked Burt Dam.

Fishing at Keg Creek begins at the small four-spot parking area located on the southwest side of the creek, just near the Route 18 bridge. From there, anglers can choose to fish upstream or downstream, depending on their preference.

The First Option for the Anglers – Upstream

Going upstream Keg Creek offers some promising options. The waterway is often not more than ten feet wide and rarely deeper than a few feet deep. The stream offers fishable

The first option for anglers looking to fish Keg Creek is to head upstream, where a variety of promising fishing opportunities await. Keg Creek, though often no more than ten feet wide and rarely deeper than a few feet, provides an intimate and accessible fishing experience. The waterway features a mix of undercut banks, deep pools, gravelly runs, and fish-holding “knuckles” of water, all set within a gently wooded landscape. This section of the creek is a favorite for those seeking a more secluded and peaceful fishing experience, with its natural charm offering a great backdrop for a day of fishing.

When approaching this stretch of Keg Creek, it is advisable to walk upstream for about fifty yards to reach the first significant bend in the creek. The meandering nature of the watercourse creates ideal fish-holding areas along the outside of the turns, where the current slows and undercut banks provide cover for steelhead and other species. These bends form natural hotspots that anglers should focus on, as they often hold fish eager to ambush anything passing by.

As you move upstream, be prepared for a bit of physical exertion. The creek’s winding path requires anglers to cross back and forth over the water several times to access the best fishing spots from the right angles. The twists and turns of the watercourse can make it difficult to stick to one side, so a bit of strategic maneuvering is necessary to fish effectively. This constant movement allows anglers to cover more water and gain better perspectives on the fish-holding structures. Whether you’re casting into deep pools, drifting through runs, or targeting undercut banks, the upstream section offers ample opportunity for those willing to put in the effort.

The Second Option for the Anglers – Downstream

Heading downstream the Keg Creek fisherman is first presented with a large deep pool on the north side of the bridge.

The pool holds fish but is also heavily fished since it is the most obvious place to start. The pool is deepest closest to the bridge, normally no more than three feet deep, and then shallows out to a few inches deep as the stream races toward Lake Ontario.

Past the pool, the topography alternates between fast sections of gravel stream, and undercut banks, with an average depth of about a foot or two. As the anglers get closer to the mouth they are faced with a wide and deep marshy pond-like section that is best fished from the west side. Keg Creek then empties into Lake Ontario through a very narrow channel.

What to Use for Fly Fishing in Keg Creek?

The approach to fly fishing in Keg Creek largely depends on the water conditions, which can vary dramatically based on rainfall and snowmelt. The volume and clarity of the water play crucial roles in determining what flies will be most effective for catching fish.

During periods of higher water flow, typically in the spring after heavy rains or snowmelt, the creek’s water may take on a light green or brownish hue, reducing visibility. In these conditions, larger flies such as woolly buggers work particularly well. Their size and profile make them more visible to fish in the murky water, and they can imitate a variety of prey, making them a go-to choice for anglers during this time. The increased water flow allows for a bit more versatility in fly size and presentation, as fish are often less wary and more willing to strike at larger, more noticeable offerings.

However, when water levels drop and the creek runs low and clear, often towards the end of the fishing cycle, it’s crucial to downsize your presentations. In these low-flow, high-clarity conditions, fish become more cautious and selective. Smaller flies, such as tiny egg imitations, are the best way to tempt steelhead and other species. In particular, an orange egg pattern—ranging from bright and vivid to a more faded, natural look—can be particularly effective. The subtle appearance of these smaller, less intrusive flies mimics the natural food sources fish are likely to be feeding on during these low-water conditions, increasing your chances of a strike. In these situations, patience and precision in your casting and presentation are key to success.

The Trick for Anglers

For anglers fishing Keg Creek, one of the most important skills is learning how to present your fly or bait in a way that doesn’t alert the fish. Steelhead and other species in the creek are highly sensitive to disturbances in the water, and any movement or unnatural presentation can easily spook them, causing them to retreat to deeper, safer areas. This is why achieving a natural drift and ensuring that your line, split shot, or other tackle don’t create any unnecessary noise or resistance is critical to success.

The key to avoiding detection is subtlety. A delicate cast is essential, and it’s important to allow the fly to flow naturally with the current. The goal is to make your presentation appear as natural as possible, whether you are using nymphs, streamers, or egg patterns. A well-executed presentation is often the difference between getting a strike and having the fish pass right by your offering.

Additional Small Egg Patterns for Fly Fishing

When it comes to egg patterns, anglers have a variety of options to choose from, depending on the specific conditions and the fish’s preferences. While smaller egg patterns are always a good choice in clear, low-water conditions, several specific egg patterns have proven particularly effective at enticing strikes. These include Glow Bugs, Nuke Egg Roe, and Sucker Spawn, each of which offers a unique appeal to fish.

Glow Bugs, for instance, are an excellent option when water clarity is low, as their bright, luminous colors can catch the attention of fish even in murky conditions. They often mimic the natural egg sac of various fish species and are highly effective at triggering a response in steelhead and other fish.

Nuke Egg Roe, another fantastic pattern, is designed to replicate the roe of salmon and steelhead. With its realistic color and size, this fly can be especially productive when you’re targeting steelhead in the post-spawn period when they’re actively looking for food.

Sucker Spawn patterns, as the name suggests, imitate the eggs of suckers and other bottom-dwelling fish. These patterns are perfect for catching steelhead during the spawn cycle, as many species are actively feeding on the eggs of these fish during this time.

Each of these egg patterns is designed to mimic a food source that fish in Keg Creek will naturally be seeking, increasing the likelihood of a strike. Depending on water conditions, fish behavior, and the time of year, anglers can experiment with different types of egg patterns to find what works best for them.

Live Bait

Live bait can also be an extremely effective method for fishing Keg Creek, particularly when the water temperature is right and the conditions align with the fish’s natural feeding patterns. This is especially true in the deeper pools near the bridge, where anglers have seen success with live baits such as nightcrawlers and minnows. For example, a local fisherman recently used a nightcrawler with a small strike indicator on light tackle and managed to hook two steelhead, proving that even simple setups can yield great results when the conditions are right.

The key to success with live bait lies in the ability to present it naturally. When fishing with worms or minnows, it’s important to allow the bait to flow naturally with the current, using a light tackle rig to avoid disturbing the water too much. A small strike indicator can help you detect when a fish has taken the bait, while still allowing the bait to drift freely in the water.

Fresh eggs are another form of live bait that can be highly effective in Keg Creek, especially when the water is lightly stained or when flows are high. Anglers often drift fresh eggs through the current, letting them pass by likely fish-holding areas without dragging or racing downstream. The slow, natural drift is key to enticing strikes, as steelhead and other species in the creek are highly attuned to the subtle movement of eggs in their environment.

Fishing behind fish, rather than casting directly at them, can also improve your chances of success. By positioning yourself downstream of a likely holding area, you can let your bait or pattern drift naturally into the fish’s strike zone, offering a more passive and natural presentation. In areas where the creek forms channels or hard turns, like those found downstream of the bridge, fish tend to congregate and are more likely to strike at well-presented bait drifting by.

In lightly stained to heavily stained water, live baits like worms, minnows, or fresh eggs can offer an irresistible temptation to steelhead and other fish. The natural appeal of these offerings, combined with a careful, well-timed drift, can often result in productive fishing in otherwise challenging conditions.

Walking Keg Creek: Secret Fishing Spots

Walking Keg Creek offers anglers a variety of challenges and rewards, with secret fishing spots nestled along its banks. For the clearest fishing access and the most stable footing, the east side of the creek is the preferred choice. Anglers can easily walk along the east side, which remains fishable almost all the way to the lake. This side of the creek offers unobstructed access to a range of prime fishing areas, making it a go-to for many anglers looking to target spring steelhead and other species.

However, as you move further downstream, the terrain can become more difficult to navigate, particularly on the west side. Thick brush and high, steep banks make walking and fishing a challenging endeavor, even just a few yards from the bridge. The west side’s dense foliage can block access, requiring anglers to carefully pick their way through to find the best spots. Despite this, there are several breaks in the foliage and paths leading down from higher ground that provide access to some prime fishing locations. These access points, although fewer in number, offer anglers the chance to fish secluded areas that are less crowded and potentially more productive.

Keg Creek is well known for offering plenty of spring steelhead fishing opportunities, but success depends heavily on the creek’s water levels. The flow of water is heavily influenced by rain and snowmelt, and it’s only when these conditions raise the stream’s levels sufficiently that the creek will breach the gravel bar at the mouth. When the water levels are right, the creek becomes a hotbed for steelhead, drawing in fish from the lake and offering anglers the chance to catch some impressive specimens.

Fishing Keg Creek requires patience, persistence, and knowledge of the terrain. Whether you’re walking the easily accessible east side or seeking out hidden gems on the west side, Keg Creek has much to offer for anglers willing to put in the effort to discover its secret spots. With the right conditions and a bit of exploration, you can find rewarding fishing experiences that make the journey worthwhile.

For fly fishing at Keg Creek, the right gear can make a significant difference in your success. Here’s a guide to what you’ll need for both fly fishing and spin casting.

Fly Fishing Equipment

Rod: A 7-9 weight, 8-10 foot rod is ideal for handling the steelhead and other species that frequent Keg Creek. This size offers a good balance of power and sensitivity to cast effectively in the varying conditions of the stream.
Backing: 150 yards of 20-pound test backing is necessary to handle the strong runs of steelhead and other fish species in the creek.
Leader: A 36-inch, 8-pound test leader provides the strength needed to manage larger fish while maintaining the finesse required for delicate presentations.
Tippet: For the tippet, use 24-36 inches of 4-6 pound test. The lighter tippet helps ensure natural drift and presentation, which is essential for enticing strikes in low-visibility water.
Fly Patterns: Effective flies include Glow Bugs, Nuke Egg Roe, Sucker Spawn, and Woolly Bugger. These patterns mimic the natural food sources for steelhead and other fish, increasing your chances of attracting a bite.

Spin Casting Equipment

Rod: A mid-weight, 5-7 foot rod is well-suited for spin casting in Keg Creek. This rod length provides the versatility to fish in tight spaces and makes casting easier in areas with overhanging branches or other obstacles.
Line: Use a 6-8 pound test line for good sensitivity and strength while maintaining a light enough presentation to fish effectively in the creek.
Bait: When spin casting, live and prepared bait can be highly effective. Red worms, night crawlers, egg sacks, and skein are all excellent choices to draw in steelhead and other species. These natural baits provide a realistic presentation, increasing your chances of a successful catch.

Whether you’re fly fishing or spin casting, the right gear and bait will ensure you’re prepared for the conditions at Keg Creek, giving you the best shot at landing a fish.

To reach Keg Creek, anglers can follow one of two routes depending on their starting point. Whether coming from Buffalo or Syracuse, the trip is straightforward but requires some attention to detail to ensure you arrive at this secluded, productive fishing location.

From Buffalo:

Take I-990 North: Start by getting onto I-990 North, which is the main route from the Buffalo area.
Turn onto NY-263 North: After traveling a few miles, turn left onto NY-263 North.
Take a left onto NY-78: Follow NY-263 for a short distance before turning left onto NY-78.
Follow NY-78 to NY-18: Continue along NY-78 for about 13.4 miles. You’ll pass through quiet countryside, enjoying views of the rural New York landscape as you approach NY-18.
Turn right onto NY-18: When you reach the junction with NY-18, turn right.
Final stretch to Keg Creek: Continue driving for approximately five more miles. Along the way, you’ll notice the natural beauty of the area. Keg Creek will be accessible via a small DEC parking lot located on the right-hand side of the road.

This route from Buffalo takes about an hour and a half, making it ideal for a day trip or longer excursion.

From Syracuse:

Take I-81 North: Begin your journey by heading north on I-81, the main interstate running through Syracuse.
Exit onto I-90 West and I-490 West: Follow I-81 until you reach the interchange with I-90 West, and merge onto I-90 West. Continue on I-90 for a short distance before taking the exit for I-490 West.
Head toward NY-36 North: Follow I-490 West until you exit onto NY-36 North in Ogden. This road will start to bring you toward the outskirts of Newfane.
Take NY-104 West to NY-18 West: Stay on NY-36 for several miles and follow the signs to NY-104 West, then take NY-104 West toward Newfane. Follow this road as it turns into NY-18 West, which will bring you closer to Keg Creek.
Final stretch: After approximately 148 miles from Syracuse, you’ll be nearing Keg Creek. The road will wind through rural landscapes, with the creek just a short distance ahead. Follow NY-18, and look for the small DEC parking lot on your right.

From Syracuse, the drive is around two and a half hours, offering a scenic journey through parts of New York’s Finger Lakes region before reaching the serene surroundings of Keg Creek.

Both routes offer easy access to one of the most beloved fishing spots in the region, where the waters of Keg Creek promise both challenge and reward for anglers. The small parking area provides a perfect place to start your adventure, so make sure to arrive early to secure a spot, especially during peak fishing times.