Chautauqua Lake Fishing – Walleye, Muskie, Bass, Panfish
In Chautauqua County in southwestern New York, Chautauqua Lake spans approximately 13,400 acres across Chautauqua County, NY. This fishery caters to both seasoned fishermen and beginners alike, offering diverse fishing experiences. Whether you’re chasing trophy walleye that haunt the depths near Point Chautauqua, battling bass in the emerald weed beds of Bemus Bay, or stalking elusive muskies lurking in the shadows of Dewittville Creek, Chautauqua Lake holds a hidden treasure for every angler.
Click so see more NY fishing spots.
Species Showcase
Walleye Fishing
Chautauqua’s walleyes reign supreme with their impressive size and feisty fights. Expect heavyweight specimens exceeding 10 pounds, with the lake record tipping the scales at a staggering 15 pounds 5 ounces and caught on May 6, 2006, by an angler named Mark Rozanski. Troll crankbaits or drift minnows near the Mayville Bar in spring and fall, or jig near humps and drop-offs in Midway State Park during summer.
Largemouth Bass and Smallmouth Bass
Largemouth and smallmouth bass thrive in the lake’s varied habitat, offering exciting opportunities for both casting and finesse techniques. Look for Bass them lurking around weed lines in Sunset Bay or Burtis Bay, around boat docks in the Chautauqua Lake Yacht Club, or near rocky shorelines like those at Point Chautauqua or Bemus Point. Topwater frogs, spinnerbaits, and Texas-rigged plastics are your summer allies, while jigs and crankbaits work wonders in fall when bass move shallower to feed.
Musky Fishing
Chautauqua Lake boasts a legendary musky fishery, drawing anglers from across the nation with its trophy potential. The lake record stands at a jaw-dropping 51 pounds 3 ounces, a testament to the giants that lurk beneath the surface. Early mornings are prime time, with large jerkbaits or bucktails enticing pre-spawn giants along weed edges near Strawberry Island or the Big Inlet. In fall, slow trolling with glide baits near Dutch Hollow Creek or Driftwood Point can yield heart-stopping strikes.
Chautauqua Hatchery, located at Prendergast Point, specializes in raising pure strain muskellunge for Chautauqua Lake and beyond. It produces 25,000-30,000 muskellunge fingerlings annually.
Panfish
Don’t overlook the abundance of panfish, including crappie, bluegill, yellow perch, and pumpkinseed. Target them in shallow areas with jigs tipped with live minnows or soft plastics in spring, or jig for them in deeper weed beds near Connley Park or Bly Point throughout the summer.
Seasonal Fishing Strategies
Spring (April-May)
Crappie and bluegill move into shallows to spawn, so cast jigs with minnows or plastics near Ashville Bay or the Mayville Community Park Boat Launch. Walleye start their prowl near shore – troll crankbaits or drift minnows in 10-20 feet of water near Bemus Point or Stow Ferry. Muskie enthusiasts can try large jerkbaits along weed edges in the early mornings near the Chautauqua Marina or Point Pleasant.
Summer (June-August)
Bass take center stage, with topwater frogs and spinnerbaits working wonders around weed lines in Shermans Bay or near Smith Boys. Deeper waters hold hungry walleye – downrig live bait near drop-offs in Irwins Bay or troll crankbaits near the Chautauqua County Boat Launch. Panfish gather in deeper weed beds, readily taking small jigs with wax worms or mealworms in Sunset Bay or Maple Springs.
Fall (September-October)
Prime time for trophy walleye! Troll crankbaits or drift minnows around rocky points and shorelines like those near Veterans Memorial Bridge or Belleview Point. Bass remain active near rocky structures and weed edges, with jigs and crankbaits producing heart-stopping strikes in Bemus Bay or Holiday Harbor. Muskie fishing transitions to slow trolling with large jerkbaits near weed edges in Goose Creek or Mud Creek.
Winter (November-March)
Ice fishing enthusiasts love Chautauqua for its productive walleye fishing. Walleye are often found in 20-30 feet of water near drop-offs in Chautauqua Lake State Park or the “Fishing Spot.” Jigging with minnow-imitating lures or spoons is the preferred method. Crappie and perch gather in shallower areas, readily taking small jigs with maggots or wax worms in Chautauqua Lake Yacht Club Marina or the Little Inlet.
Seasonal Lure and Bait Shifts
Adapt your bait and lure choices based on the season and water temperature. Live bait is great in spring and fall, while artificial lures work well in summer and winter. For example, try nightcrawlers for walleye near the in spring or crankbaits for bass around the weed flats in Warner Bay in summer.
Lake Access
Accessing this bounty is easy thanks to numerous boat ramps and public access points. Whether you’re launching your own vessel or renting a pontoon, these convenient locations put you within striking distance of your target species. See the NY Dec Website
Landmarks & Fishing Tips
Whitessides Point: This rocky point near Stow Ferry attracts hungry smallmouth bass in the summer, especially when casting jigs or crankbaits near the drop-off.
Willow Brook: This tributary stream entering the lake near Bemus Bay offers excellent opportunities for fly fishing for smallmouth bass and panfish, particularly in the spring and fall.
Point Chautauqua: This historic point boasts a protected cove that holds crappie and bluegill populations year-round. Cast jigs tipped with wax worms near the docks or boat launch for an afternoon of fun.
Vukote Bar: This shallow area near Ashville Bay is a haven for panfish in the summer. Drift minnows or jig with small plastics for crappie, bluegill, and yellow perch.
Experiences beyond the Boat
Ready for Sailing: Chautauqua Lake offers fantastic sailing opportunities, with rentals available at Holiday Harbor or Chautauqua Marina. Enjoy a scenic cruise or participate in the annual Chautauqua Regatta.
Shores Acres: This family-friendly area features a sandy beach, boat rentals, and fishing charters. Cast from the shores for panfish or take a guided trip for walleye or bass.
Sunset Bay: This bay is ideal for shore fishing, particularly early mornings or evenings. Target bass and panfish along the weed lines or cast jigs from the Chautauqua Lake Yacht Club pier.
