How to Catch Brown Trout
Catching trophy brown trout is a challenge that requires specific tactics, as the biggest browns behave differently than their smaller, more predictable cousins. These large, slab-sided fish are opportunistic feeders, often hiding in unexpected locations, elusive to even the most seasoned anglers. Over 30 years of fishing experience has taught me a systematic approach to consistently connect with Lake Ontario’s largest brown trout.
Prime Locations for Trophy Browns
Rock Formations: Key to Big Brown Habitat
One of the best places to find trophy brown trout in Lake Ontario is near broken rock structures along the shoreline. Unlike smaller trout, the largest browns gravitate to cobble rock formations, which provide both cover and an ideal environment for ambushing prey. Here are three prime locations:
- Hungerford Shoal (between Pultneyville and Ontario): This spot is known for its distinctive broken rock structure, surrounded by pea gravel. It warms quickly in the spring, creating ideal conditions for early-season trout.
- Shore Oaks (east of Oswego Harbor): This area offers a rocky shoreline with several shallows and shelves, making it a magnet for larger browns.
- Stony Point Lighthouse to Stony Creek (near Henderson Harbor): This region includes several bays, such as Sawyer’s and Ray’s Bay, which are famous for yielding massive browns. These bays feature diverse underwater structures and are prime feeding grounds for big fish.
Understanding Warm Water and Brown Trout Patterns
Springtime temperature changes, even by just a few degrees, can have a dramatic effect on brown trout behavior. The areas listed above all share a crucial trait: they’re located near warm water flows, estuaries, or sandy beaches, which warm faster than surrounding waters.
For example, Hungerford Shoal’s rocky structure, bordered by pea gravel, allows it to absorb sunlight quickly, creating warmer, nutrient-rich waters that attract minnows, a key food source for brown trout. On the eastern basin, areas like Stony Point and Shore Oaks offer cobble rock zones close to warm water sources. These warmer pockets of water draw in trout early in the season, concentrating them in fishable areas and increasing the odds of hooking larger specimens.
Why Big Browns Favor Cobble Rock
While smaller browns often roam around sandy or gravelly bottoms, the largest browns prefer the complexity of cobble rock. This type of structure offers them several advantages:
- Ambush Points: The jagged rocks and crevices provide excellent cover for these stealthy predators, allowing them to remain hidden until prey comes near.
- Food Abundance: Cobble rock areas typically support a healthy population of baitfish, such as alewives and gobies, which are a staple for larger browns.
- Thermal Comfort: The uneven rock surfaces can hold warmth better than open water, providing a comfortable temperature for trout in the early spring.
Tactics for Hooking Trophy Browns
Fine-Tuning Depth Control with Planer Boards and Downriggers
Big browns are sensitive to light and temperature, often staying deeper in the water column. Using planer boards and downriggers allows you to target different depths effectively. Adding weights like 3-ounce Gibb sinkers or using mini-diver disks can help get your lures down to the right level in slightly deeper water. For example, setting lines at depths between 15 and 30 feet can be optimal when the water warms in spring.
Choosing the Right Lures and Colors
In Lake Ontario, color can make a significant difference. Over the last decade, gold patterns have become highly effective for browns, especially in the eastern basin. Here are three go-to patterns for targeting big browns:
- Gold Perch: Mimics local baitfish and works well in slightly murky waters.
- Gold Tuxedo: A solid choice for clearer water, as it has a reflective quality that attracts fish from a distance.
- Sodus Point Buckeye: Known for its versatility, this lure is particularly effective for larger browns near shorelines with broken rock.
By slowing the trolling speed to around 2.2 knots, you allow these lures to hover near baitfish schools, giving browns more time to strike.
Maximizing the Thermocline
During late spring, the thermocline begins to form, providing a defined layer where big browns are more likely to hold. By adjusting your setup with divers, downriggers, and weights, you can align your presentation to the depth of the thermocline, often around 15 to 30 feet in early-season waters. A slower trolling speed allows lures to linger near baitfish schools clustered in this zone, creating prime conditions for attracting larger fish.
Patience and Precision: Keys to Success
Successfully targeting trophy brown trout is a blend of patience, adaptability, and understanding the lake’s nuances. Each trip may require adjustments to the setup based on water conditions, weather, and baitfish activity. As you experiment with these tactics and focus on the cobble rock areas, the odds of landing a massive brown trout increase.
Bait for Brown Trout
Goby Minnows
In recent years, round goby minnows have become the top springtime bait for large brown trout in Lake Ontario. A look inside any brown trout caught in April or May often reveals multiple gobies in its stomach. These bottom-dwelling fish provide nourishment with minimal effort for browns, making them a favored food source and a key to catching trophy trout in the spring.
Why Goby Minnows Attract Big Browns
Broken Rocky Bottoms Are Ideal Habitat
Round gobies thrive in broken, rocky areas, where they find both protection and food. This habitat preference coincidentally aligns with the areas where trophy brown trout are commonly found, especially in spring. During the 2011 fishing season, some brown trout were found with as many as 15 gobies in their stomachs, showing just how important this bait has become.
Shadows for Concealment
When sunlight hits broken rock, it casts a range of shadows that both gobies and big trout use for camouflage. These shadows help browns stalk gobies undetected, while turbid water and sediment stirred up by wind provide even more cover for trout. Brown trout can hunt efficiently in these conditions, expending minimal energy while feasting on gobies. For anglers, targeting these shadowed, turbid areas can yield great success.
Skinny Water Holds Big Browns
One surprising observation is that some of the largest brown trout often hunt gobies in very shallow water. In June 2011, we landed multiple trout over 10 pounds in less than five feet of water. In one instance, a Michigan Stinger spoon trolled on an inside planer board rod hooked a 16½-pound brown in just 4½ feet of water. These shallow zones, particularly where goby populations are high and the water column is stirred up with sediment, can attract large browns—and anglers who know where to look have the place to themselves.
Key Takeaways for Targeting Trophy Browns with Goby Minnow Patterns
- Focus on Rocky Bottoms: Look for broken rock areas where gobies hide.
- Shallow, Murky Water: Don’t be afraid to fish in shallow, slightly turbid water where big browns hunt.
- Leverage Shadows: Fish on overcast days or in areas where shadows are cast by underwater structures, as browns use these shadows to ambush gobies.
Understanding how goby minnows influence brown trout behavior can transform an average day of fishing into one filled with trophy catches.
Using the Right Tackle
When it comes to catching brown trout, the Saiff Fleet is all about spoon fishing. Years ago, after dealing with tangled lines, spiked fish, and losing too many trophy browns on plugs, I switched exclusively to spoons. Today, spoon fishing remains our primary tactic, especially for spring trout in Lake Ontario.
Seasonal Spoons for Brown Trout
Spring Favorites
During spring, Michigan Stingers are our go-to spoons for trout. Their lightweight design and durable treble hooks make them ideal for shallow water and light trolling. As water conditions change, so do our tactics. In summer, we sometimes switch to NK-28s, and when baitfish are smaller, Northern King “C-5” or Sutton “West River” spoons are solid options. Each has a reputation for attracting browns, making spoons essential tools in our brown trout strategy.
Clear Water Calls for Fast Action
In clear water, presentation is everything. Michigan Stingers, with their lightweight build and strong treble hook, provide an edge. They can tolerate speeds over three knots, which is essential when faster presentations are necessary. With a large enough hook gap, they ensure a solid grip on a brown trout’s jaw, minimizing the chance of losing a hooked fish.
Trolling Tactics and Speed Control
When spoon fishing, we aim to keep our lures near the top of the water column at a moderate trolling speed. This shallow presentation lets us target browns hiding in skinny water. To optimize lure movement, we use a #2 round-nosed snap clip, which enhances the spoon’s action on the line.
The Ideal Line Setup
Our tackle setup includes 15-pound Trilene Big Game, a co-filament line that’s abrasion-resistant and ideal for Lake Ontario’s rugged conditions. To prevent line twist, we attach a small bead chain at the end, followed by a seven-foot fluorocarbon leader. Fluorocarbon is nearly invisible underwater, enhancing lure presentation, especially on clear days.
Lessons Learned the Hard Way
Years ago, in the last hour of a fishing derby, I had a massive brown trout on a plug close to the boat. My client played it perfectly until it rolled, and the light wire hooks straightened out just before netting. Watching that trophy brown slip away changed my approach; since then, I’ve relied on spoons—and haven’t looked back.
Key Colors for Success
Choosing the right colors can make or break a fishing day. We rotate through several Michigan Stinger colors, but the basics that deliver consistently are:
- Emerald Shiner
- Tuxedo
- Perch
- Grim Reaper
- Sodus Point Buckeye
- Fat Nancy Wiggler
These base colors provide a solid foundation for success in Lake Ontario’s varying conditions and will help you stay on the fish all season long.
Fishing with spoons isn’t just effective; it’s reliable, helping anglers avoid losing trophy fish and keep big browns coming. This approach, from speed control to tackle choice, can help you consistently hook into the largest browns Lake Ontario has to offer.
Quality Not Quantity
When it comes to brown trout fishing, it’s all about quality, not quantity. Knowing how to catch brown trout in Lake Ontario means deciding between a high number of fish or targeting truly large browns. If you’re after trophy-sized trout, you’ll need to focus on specific tactics and locations—and often avoid the most popular fishing spots.
Avoid the Crowds for Big Browns
While fishing where the fleet is congregating might bring in 30 fish in under two hours, these fish are usually smaller. Big browns are wary and prefer undisturbed, quieter waters. To consistently catch larger trout, avoid crowded areas and seek out secluded fishing grounds. The payoff is in quality: less fish but a better chance at those hefty browns.
Temperature Matters: Southern Shore in Spring
Water temperature is key when looking for big browns. In early April, start on Lake Ontario’s southern shore, from Sodus Point to Irondequoit Bay, where waters warm first. Big browns congregate here, drawn to warmer currents. As May rolls around, shift your focus to the shorelines stretching from Oswego to Henderson Harbor for optimal conditions and more trophy trout opportunities.
Find the Rock Piles
Cobble rock formations are hotspots for trophy browns, and Henderson Harbor is an underrated destination for large brown trout. It doesn’t see as much fishing pressure as other popular locations, making it ideal for landing big fish in undisturbed waters. Time your trips well, and you’ll find yourself in prime conditions with little competition.
Original Article By Captain Bill Saiff III
About The Author
Capt. Bill Saiff III owns and operates the Saiff Charter Fleet in Henderson Harbor, NY. For more information, visit the team online at BillSaiffOutdoors.com.
