Oak Orchard Creek Fishing – Species, Seasons, and Tips

Explore Marsh Creek and Oak Orchard Creek: Ultimate Fishing Guide

Oak Orchard Creek, in Orleans County, New York, offers anglers an excellent cold-water fishing experience. The surrounding area includes towns such as Albion, Medina, and Kent, creating a tranquil backdrop for fishing enthusiasts.

Connected to Lake Ontario, Oak Orchard Creek serves as a vital Lake Ontario tributary, known for its exceptional fishing opportunities. With a depth of 40 feet on average and reaching 73 feet at its deepest points, Oak Orchard Creek provides diverse habitats for various fish species. The 535-acre Oak Orchard Creek, within this scenic landscape, is not only abundantly stocked with fish but also attracts numerous waterfowl during migration, enhancing the overall fishing experience.

A brown trout lying in the grass alongside a fly rod and reel.

Oak Orchard Creek, often referred to as Oak Orchard River, is recognized for its role as a tributary to Lake Ontario. Flowing through the Oak Orchard Creek Marsh, a designated National Natural Landmark, the creek covers 600 acres. The location where the river meets up with Marsh Creek is a great place for fishing, known as “the Bridges”.

The fishing experience in these water bodies is marked by the excitement of catching brown trout, rainbow trout, chinook, and coho salmon. The runs of these fish species make Oak Orchard Creek renowned destinations for cold-water fishing in New York State.

Experience other productive fishing spots in NY State.

Seasonal Fishing Techniques

Spring (March – May)

As spring unfolds, Oak Orchard Creek becomes vibrant with trout activity. Brown trout take center stage during this season, exhibiting voracious feeding habits. 

Anglers targeting Brown Trout are advised to explore the lake’s shorelines and the mouths of tributaries, where warmer waters attract these elusive creatures. Employing simple spinning or trolling setups proves effective for a successful spring outing.

A hand holds a small brown trout.

Rainbow trout as well as landlocked Atlantic salmon, become a prime target for advanced fishermen. Casting lures close to the bottom in colder waters remains a reliable technique, promising a rewarding experience in Oak Orchard Creek. These water bodies, each with its unique fishery, offer diverse opportunities for anglers to enjoy the warming weather and pursue a variety of trout species.

A close-up image of a large rainbow trout.

Summer (June – August)

As summer takes hold, Oak Orchard Creek transforms into a hotspot for walleye fishing and panfish angling. The prime walleye fishing season typically extends from June through August, inviting anglers to explore the creeks in search of these prized catches. Understanding walleye behavior is key during this season. Walleye often move to deeper waters during the day and come closer to shore in the early morning and evening, particularly near submerged rocks, fallen trees, or deeper holes.

A young man stands holding a large walleye.

While walleye fishing takes the spotlight, panfish like perch and rock bass provide exciting opportunities for anglers in Oak Orchard Creek. Fine-tuning presentation techniques can enhance your success with these species. For instance, try using slip bobber rigs to suspend live bait like minnows or worms at precise depths near structures where panfish congregate. Experiment with different jigging motions and retrieve speeds to entice bites from these elusive panfish.

Fall (September – November)

Fall brings a spectacular chinook and choho salmon run in Oak Orchard Creek as these fish make their way back to their spawning grounds. The salmon fishing season, extending into November, offers excellent opportunities for anglers targeting salmon.

A close-up image of a fly rod sitting in a fishing net. Trolling remains a popular and effective technique, with salmon actively feeding before their spawning journey. In addition to salmon, trout fishing continues to be rewarding in the fall. 

Brown and lake trout, still present in good numbers, provide thrilling experiences for anglers in Oak Orchard Creek. The backdrop of fall foliage adds to the beauty, making these water bodies ideal destinations for those seeking the thrill of the catch amid the changing seasons.

Winter (December – February)

Winter transforms Oak Orchard Creek into challenging yet rewarding destinations for ice fishing enthusiasts. The frozen lakes offer unique opportunities to target various cold-water species.

The tributary streams, including Marsh Creek and Oak Orchard Creek, present possibilities for fishing brook and rainbow trout even in the coldest weather. Anglers should remain vigilant for occasional opportunities for steelhead fishing at the mouths of tributaries where open water may be present. 

A fisherman holds a large rainbow trout.

As winter progresses, the ice-covered lakes become havens for those willing to brave the cold and pursue the challenges of winter fishing in Oak Orchard Creek.

What Oak Orchard Creek is Known For

The annual stocking efforts by the New York Department of Environmental Conservation enhance the fishing experience, with 21,000 rainbow trout, 155,000 chinook salmon, and 26,000 coho salmon released into Oak Orchard River, along with 7,100 rainbow trout in Marsh Creek. 

Angler holds up a double-figure coho salmon.

The convergence of these water bodies at “The Bridges” creates a unique fishing environment, attracting anglers seeking the thrill of catching these prized species. The area is governed by Lake Ontario tributary regulations, ensuring sustainable and enjoyable fishing experiences for all.

Boat Ramps, Boat Launches, Marinas, and Public Access Points

For those interested in accessing Oak Orchard Creek, Point Breeze, NY, serves as a key location. Situated at the mouth of Oak Orchard Creek, this area provides public access points for fishing and boating. Travelers from Rochester, NY, can take US Rte. 104 west to NYS Rte. 98 north, leading to Point Breeze. 

Public boat ramps and launches are available, allowing visitors to enjoy the fishing opportunities, including the chance to catch brown trout, rainbow trout, and salmon in the waters of Oak Orchard Creek.

Oak Orchard Creek and Related Fishing Articles

Lake Ontario's tributaries offer exceptional fishing with seasonal tips, diverse species, and convenient access points for anglers to explore and enjoy.

Lake Ontario Tributary Species Each fall, the tributaries of Lake Ontario become a magnet for anglers seeking trophy fishing opportunities. While the main draw is often the chance to land a thirty-pound

Summertime Lake Ontario Tributary Fishing Lake Ontario’s tributary fishing has earned a reputation as a trophy fishery, significantly boosting the local economy in that region of New York. Anglers flock to these

How to Catch Brown Trout Catching trophy brown trout is a challenge that requires specific tactics, as the biggest browns behave differently than their smaller, more predictable cousins. These large, slab-sided fish

Where to Fish for Musky in New York State Catching a muskellunge, or muskie, is no small feat—experienced anglers will tell you that success is never guaranteed. Muskies are elusive, challenging, and

FAQs About Fishing Oak Orchard Creek

Oak Orchard Creek boasts a diverse range of fish species, making it a haven for anglers seeking various challenges and catches. Casting spoons, plugs, and flies along the creek can yield strikes from brown trout, offering an exciting fishing experience. Additionally, Oak Orchard Creek is known to be home to steelhead, coho salmon, and smallmouth bass. Tailoring your fishing approach to the specific species you’re targeting is crucial for success. Understanding the seasonal migrations and feeding habits of brown trout, steelhead, coho salmon, and smallmouth bass can guide your choice of lures, bait, and fishing techniques. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or a novice, exploring the diverse fishery of Oak Orchard Creek provides ample opportunities for a rewarding fishing adventure.

Your NY Fishing Newsletter